Exploring Neutrality: Objective Truth or Convenient Facade?
A 60-minute session on staying neutral: between a mother and a wife, two friends who have split up, two colleagues at war, siblings dividing a house, and strangers being mistreated in front of us. Is refusing to take sides fairness, or a comfortable way out? Twelve independent cards; open three or four.
The opening question
When two people you love start arguing in front of you, what's your honest first move: jump in, pick a side, crack a joke, or quietly leave the room?
Everyone in the room answers this in one line before any card is opened. Write the answers down; you will come back to them.
The cards
12 ways into the topic
Each card is independent. Your group votes on which to open, and four or five is plenty for an hour. Behind every card sit three prompts, one at a time, that only appear once it is opened on the board. Unopened cards keep for next time.
- 1
Between Mother And Wife
Your mother and your wife are not speaking. Each one tells you her side of the story. Each one is waiting to see whose side you take.
- 2
When Friends Break Up
Two of your closest friends have split up. Both still message you. Both want to know whose birthday party you're going to.
- 3
When Colleagues Fall Out
Two people on your team can't stand each other. Each one complains to you over chai about the other. You nod along with both.
- 4
When Relatives Say Offensive Things
At a family lunch, an elder makes a nasty joke about a cousin's dark skin. A few people laugh. Everyone else stares at their plate.
- 5
Family Property Fights
The family flat has to be divided. Your brother wants to sell. Your sister wants to keep it. Both call you, asking you to back them.
- 6
Taking Sides In Kids' Fights
Your two children are fighting over the remote. Both are shouting, “She started it!” Both are looking at you to decide.
- 7
When Parents Argue
Your parents had a fight. Later, your mother asks, “You saw it. Tell me, was I wrong?” Your father is waiting for your answer too.
- 8
Never Giving Your Opinion
Someone asks what you think. You say, “It depends,” or “Both sides have a point.” Everyone nods and moves on.
- 9
Minding Your Own Business
You grew up hearing, “Don't get involved in other people's matters.” Now there's loud shouting from the flat next door. You turn the TV up.
- 10
When A Stranger Is Mistreated
At a restaurant, a customer is yelling at a young waiter over a small mistake. The waiter keeps saying sorry. Every other table goes quiet.
- 11
Looking For Unbiased News
Everyone says they just want news without any bias. But when a channel agrees with you, it feels fair. When it doesn't, it feels biased.
- 12
Why Staying Out Is Wise
Some fights end only because one person refused to join them.
The line to leave with
The last time you said you were staying neutral, who was it actually protecting: them, or you?
More boards,more ways in.
Every discussion we have run has a board behind it. Browse them by topic.